Since when are you the person that decides whether or not a website is a good community?
You say that smogon has more members than us, yet you don't compare how long each has been up, or how many of those members joined and left.
EDIT: I just had a look, and after 1 month (longer than this site has been up) it only had 169 members.
Also, almost half of its current members have made 5 or less posts.