[BUG] In-game trader Pokemon flagged illegal

[Jimmy Cerno]

I'm posting to inform the devs about this issue. Here is a link to the collection of what i found back a month ago, and a c&p of what gets flagged: 

 

Japanese Blue

 

Slowpoke
Gengar
Golem
Kangaskhan
Beedrill

RG (JAP) RB (INT) English Japanese

Beedrill

Yellow English French German Spanish Italian Japanese

Parasect
Dugtrio
Machamp
Beedrill

Yellow Unused English Japanese

Beedrill

GS English French German Spanish Italian Japanese Korean

Rhydon

Crystal English French Spanish Italian Japanese

Dodrio
Magneton

Crystal German

Shuckle

FRLG French

Lickitung

FRLG German

Nidoran♀
Nidoran♂
Jynx

DP French

Magikarp

DP Korean

Magikarp

Pt French

Magikarp

Pt Korean

Magikarp

HGSS Korean

Pikachu

BW French

Munchlax
Rotom
Cottonee
Petilil
Basculin-Red
Basculin-Blue
Emolga

B2W2 French

Alakazam
Ambipom
Rotom
Gigalith
Cottonee

XY Italian

Magikarp

XY Spanish

Farfetch'd

[Kaphotics]

Updated with the following exceptions/contradictions:

https://github.com/kwsch/PKHeX/commit/be285917b9f2c3e33e7ec54be1207bbcb7315156

JP Blue:

• Invalid catch rate (120), should be 45.
• Beedrill: Unused, impossible to encounter as the trade is not available in game.

GER FRLG:

• Nidoran: WALTRAU is 7 characters, WALTRAUD is 8 (too long). Not sure what is correct. Changed to 7chars
• Jynx: Has 2 spaces at the end of OT. Not sure if this is correct. Kept as is

[BlackShark]

37 minutes ago, Kaphotics said:

Jynx: Has 2 spaces at the end of OT. Not sure if this is correct. Kept as is

The two spaces are correct. It can even be see in the trading screen.

124 - SCHMUSI - 705F498A2E1D.pk3

[Kaphotics]

Heh, thanks for checking

Updated: https://github.com/kwsch/PKHeX/commit/7ef8a88678adc23e08e374f3d52bd3524090e20e

[Jimmy Cerno]

So I tried the new release, and it flags the following Pokemon:

Japanese Blue

Gengar

Golem

Problem: Unable to match an encounter flag and invalid Catch Rate when checked on the versions of gen 1.

Yellow all regions

Machamp

Problem: Same as above.

Korean gen 4 games

Magikarp DP Platinum

Pikachu HGSS

Problem: These Pokemon are flagged on Korean versions for incompatibility despite being in those games through normal play.

[qrst]

I don't know what information I need to provide but when a legitimately-acquired Kadabra from Granite Cave in ORAS got legitimately-traded into Alakazam it shows error "invalid: Unable to match an encounter from origin game". Original encounter happened as Abra at level 10.

Edited May 8, 2018 by qrst

[theSLAYER]

1 minute ago, qrst said:

I don't know what information I need to provide but when a legitimately-acquired Kadabra got legitimately-traded into Alakazam it shows error "invalid: Unable to match an encounter from origin game".

Upload the file, and we will take a look 

[qrst]

Here is the file:
N.B.: It's self traded by Citra, & this specific pokemon has no kind of hack on it (I hacked others ).
N.B.: I just remembered Lucky egg is Hacked too  .

main

Edited May 8, 2018 by qrst

[wwwwwwzx]

Self trading is not treated as legal. The pokemon that evolves by trade and doesn't have the memory of lastest handler is unnatural.

Edited May 8, 2018 by wwwwwwzx

[qrst]

Oh got it! Sorry for the false alarm.

Edited May 8, 2018 by qrst