Beta: the pokécheck legality checker for generation 5

[marcos9191]

I think (only as a suggestion) you could add "provably because nick was changed after hatching" into the warning "This Pokémon is missing DPPt hatch trash bytes" and "This Pokémon is missing HG/SS hatch trash bytes", is the only legal chance to have them so if don't have DPPl or HG/SS trash bytes.

[Agonist]

I think (only as a suggestion) you could add "provably because nick was changed after hatching" into the warning "This Pokémon is missing DPPt hatch trash bytes" and "This Pokémon is missing HG/SS hatch trash bytes", is the only legal chance to have them so if don't have DPPl or HG/SS trash bytes.

Why bother?

[dcrispell7]

False Positive:

http://www.pokecheck.org/?pk=3081795 Magnet Rise shows up as hacked/Event only when it is a valid HG/SS move tutor

[marcos9191]

Why bother?

To avoid create confusion, but just it's a suggestion

[Hozu]

http://www.smogon.com/forums/showpost.php?p=4376835&postcount=959

Unless the Poketransfer function does something funny with Pokerus shouldn't any strain be possible without restrictions? As in 0-4 days duration, strains 1-15? Because if I can get strain 8.X in Emerald for example, I could pass that onwards to 5th gen and infect Unova origin mons with it. Right now 8.X is flagged as illegal.

Edit: That post may be wrong. Bond is looking into 3rd gen again. However my point still stands, unless some strains are impossible in all games of course.

[luftbandiger]

I am getting Rock Head as a hacked ability for a blue-stripped Basculin.

http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3011403

[Agonist]

To avoid create confusion, but just it's a suggestion

If there's any confusion, it's because people don't bother to actually read, and comprehend what's being said.

[justpaul95]

Celebi should only be in a Cherish or Pokeball but Pokecheck says a Master Ball is valid

https://www.pokecheck.org/?screenshot=3117889&la

[Agonist]

In a similar vein, the only way to get Mew in a Pokeball other than the default, and Cherish ball is through Emerald, and only on Japanese versions.

[Hozu]

http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=2830639

Korean B/W2 is a valid game version now.

[dantherip]

http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3132468

What does "Shiny-check triggered Manaphy egg" mean?

[Hozu]

http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3132468

What does "Shiny-check triggered Manaphy egg" mean?

It means that it would have been shiny on the original save file it was obtained on, hence the anti-shiny measures kicked in. That changes the PID, and since it is predictable, that is the message you get.

What's up with this one? http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3132447

There is no message on the PID line at all.

[Trashsetter]

Found something strange on the legality analysis of my luxtra

A friend of mine chained this one in his Diamond Edition, but the legality analysis says it's hacked! https://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3092905

How comes that?

[Propoke]

The checks for a few White 2/Black 2 PID's seem a bit dodgy.

By that I mean, there are a few that are being marked as invalid when they were obtained in the game.

A Samurott: http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3148521

A Lucario: http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3148521

Samurott was a starter, and Lucario evolved from a Riolu obtained from the dream world.

[Kaphotics]

Lucario (bad url) - http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3148542

user's account: all private ~ http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=search&tid=%40propoke&notpub=1

[Propoke]

If you want them public:

Lucario: http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3148542

Samurott: http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3148521

The Lucario link I posted works. Maybe because it was private?

I normally set my pokemon to private as I keep changing the ones on there, updating them as I go about training them.

[Dark Ray]

Dream Radar and Game version Black/White do not go together. http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=2709354

[Hozu]

If you want them public:

Lucario: http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3148542

Samurott: http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3148521

The Lucario link I posted works. Maybe because it was private?

I normally set my pokemon to private as I keep changing the ones on there, updating them as I go about training them.

"Oh no my hacks are showing up as hacked. Something is wrong here!"

Legality analysis is working properly.

Edited January 6, 2013 by Hozu

[dantherip]

Hi

I feel kinda violated by Hozu throwing all my failed trades up on the chat after he muted me, at least let me explain why they are there.

Also the Wallmart Chimchar is released with fakeout as a move seeing as it is a male I would guess that it would be able to pass the move down and therefore making it a non-event move?

Here is the Chimchar in question- https://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3101226

Also why did he say this Mew is fake: https://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3044357, I traded my Meloetta for that, is there something I should know here?

Also I apologize for my outburst, I got unnecessary angry over the "Lern2read comment" as I felt that was rude.

If this is the wrong place to post this then please delete this and direct me towards the correct place.

[Agonist]

Hi

I feel kinda violated by Hozu throwing all my failed trades up on the chat after he muted me, at least let me explain why they are there.

Also the Wallmart Chimchar is released with fakeout as a move seeing as it is a male I would guess that it would be able to pass the move down and therefore making it a non-event move?

Here is the Chimchar in question- https://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3101226

Also why did he say this Mew is fake: https://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3044357, I traded my Meloetta for that, is there something I should know here?

Also I apologize for my outburst, I got unnecessary angry over the "Lern2read comment" as I felt that was rude.

If this is the wrong place to post this then please delete this and direct me towards the correct place.

Can't say why the Mew is hacked, but it definitely is. Additionally, there are quite a few other terrible hacks associated with your account that you promptly deleted when it was mentioned. Finally, the Hacked / Event only (###) is pretty self-explanatory, so it really shouldn't need to be explained once, let alone four or five times.

Oh, and it's up to the moderators/admins discretion on who to mute; if they muted you, it's because they had a good reason (and Hozu did).

[dantherip]

Can't say why the Mew is hacked, but it definitely is. Additionally, there are quite a few other terrible hacks associated with your account that you promptly deleted when it was mentioned. Finally, the Hacked / Event only (###) is pretty self-explanatory, so it really shouldn't need to be explained once, let alone four or five times.

Oh, and it's up to the moderators/admins discretion on who to mute; if they muted you, it's because they had a good reason (and Hozu did).

Thanks for the answer, there where 2 hacks associated with my account, one I received over at pokemongts(the shiny Manaphy) and one I received over at Serebii(the shiny Thunderus). I deleted them because I felt violated and I do a lot of trading and didn't want my trading name tarnished because of 2 dumb hacks on my account, afterall they where only in there because I wanted to check them.

I'm sorry about asking too many times, it didn't really sink in until QouteM, I didn't realize you guys wasn't saying it was a hack (inb4 dipshit I know, you made that quite clear).

Last thing and then I won't bother you guys anymore, what would you do with the Mew? Try to get back in touch with the guy you traded it with(about a month ago ca) or just released and be done with it?

Also I fully accept being muted/banned.

Edited January 7, 2013 by dantherip
Additional info

[Agonist]

I'd release the Mew since it's a hack, but it's up to you.

[shiroji]

(please forgive this if it double posts, I thought this thread was for Gen 5 only)

I don't know if this has been addressed but I uploaded Mindy's Haunter from Platinum and the LA has red text in several places.

ID/SID

PID

Locations

Is there a reason for that?

http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=detail&uid=3213163

Edited January 12, 2013 by shiroji
misspelled "thread"

[Hozu]

Looks like that Haunter hasn't been added as an exception due to being an in-game trade. Don't worry about it.

[Hozu]

Do the wondercards themselves say somewhere what game they can be from? I made the silly mistake of not realizing that a certain wondercard was from B/W2 only when I injected it into B/W1, and the LA didn't say anything was wrong.