The problem I had with it was, I didn't know I was only supposed to mark ONE so yeah. It's all good now, thanks guys for the responses.
Another thing I'm having trouble with now is that (this is actually quite common), well I'm playing the US version of Soul Silver (emulator/rom), and whenever I get past the Goldenrod Gym, after I go north and get into a couple battles and try to save afterwards, game will crash on me... and yeah. I have no idea how to fix this. I've seen fixes for the Japanese versions but yeah, it didn't really work for the US version.
Any help will be greatly appreciated!
P.S. I play on the NO$GBA Emulator.