Jump to content
evandixon

The Avatar/Signature Rating Thread

Recommended Posts

I have noticed that many peoiple make separate threads for asking opinions on avatars and signatures. Well, this thread is dedicated to that, so there won't be an overflow of threads in the Creative discussion thread.

I recommend that you date your signatures and avatars, because they change over time (my signature the the most unstable in the forum, so I think).

To start this thread off, why don't we cristen it by starting it off with a rating request:

cl_xana_evandixon_ava.png

6/22/2009

Be sure to request a rating here, rather than creationg your own thread.

Edited by evandixon

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

8/10

Just an image with a simple background and text. The image is a bit rough...but its a nice, simple avatar :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Its pretty cool :D

Nice and simple like Naru-chu said

8/10

Rate my new sig whould you guys?

10/10

Wow, just wow.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

10/10 combines sasuke, with a completely fit backround completely shows off his awesomeness. it also has great quality.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7/10

You overdid it a little in my opinion.

Explain please.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That's a nice new sig Naru-chu :D

Deidara right?

Yep! He would still be alive if not for telo-I mean Sasuke. xD Using Manda as a shield was good thinking though lol.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
He has quite a cool "art" as he calls it.

He has too many mouths...0.o

But yea, exploding clay is pretty cool.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Explain please.

All of the graphics of each side of the person in the middle. But it is just opinion, because I'm more of a simple graphic person. Example: I thought that the title screen for Pokemon Ranger 2 was the best, because they didn't over-do it. They just put a simple "Pokemon Ranger" in the middle of a landscape.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
All of the graphics of each side of the person in the middle. But it is just opinion, because I'm more of a simple graphic person. Example: I thought that the title screen for Pokemon Ranger 2 was the best, because they didn't over-do it. They just put a simple "Pokemon Ranger" in the middle of a landscape.

Oh, I though my graphics actually looked bad. Yeah, more images makes it look a bit more messy and crowded, but its my signature effect.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been refraining from making sigs for a while, because I like the freedom to use a large render and really show off lighting and smudging.

Anyway, a different kind of thing that didn't fit into my smudge thread. A few things I know about it: 1. Alienware probably owes me some money. 2. I will never see a cent from Alienware. 3. I have recently discovered that Dell owns Alienware. (O.o)

Alienwaread.jpg

By the way, I made a mistake on it. See if you can find it. (stupid apply image =|)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I've been refraining from making sigs for a while, because I like the freedom to use a large render and really show off lighting and smudging.

Anyway, a different kind of thing that didn't fit into my smudge thread. A few things I know about it: 1. Alienware probably owes me some money. 2. I will never see a cent from Alienware. 3. I have recently discovered that Dell owns Alienware. (O.o)

Alienwaread.jpg

By the way, I made a mistake on it. See if you can find it. (stupid apply image =|)

Well, I know Apply Image blends two images (am I right?), I'm guessing the words "Feel the Power" aren't that visible? lol probably way off.

And Illithian, care to rate my sig? I know you're a way better artist than me and I'd love your opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well, I know Apply Image blends two images (am I right?), I'm guessing the words "Feel the Power" aren't that visible? lol probably way off.

And Illithian, care to rate my sig? I know you're a way better artist than me and I'd love your opinion.

Firstly, in Photoshop, if you make a new blank layer and go Image -> Apply Image, it takes whatever you have currently in all your layers, flattens (combines them), and copies it onto the blank layer. Its for background safety, but it also has some useful stuff, such as using Overlay to darken the image.

Secondly, no, the words Feel the Power are supposed to be slightly erased, although you're closer then you think.

Finally, sure I'll rate your sig. ;)

Firstly, I like how you included the fractal render and I think the main render (image) is blended in well, and looks great. However, I do think you tried to put too much in one sig. The problem with sigs is they're small. You've probably already seen how hard it is to get a lot into a single sig, and thats why I like making larger images, even though they can't really be used as sigs.

However, even though theres too much on the sig itself, I think you did a great job making the main render more visible and more important then the other renders, and I also think considering how much is on the sig, it actually looks suprisingly good. But for future reference, its a lot harder to fit quite a few renders into a single sig and make it look any good. Still, great job on that sig.

I'll rate it 8/10, because:

-Too crowded

+Great blending

+Use of fractal

+Looks impressive

=)

Cheers.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Firstly, in Photoshop, if you make a new blank layer and go Image -> Apply Image, it takes whatever you have currently in all your layers, flattens (combines them), and copies it onto the blank layer. Its for background safety, but it also has some useful stuff, such as using Overlay to darken the image.

Secondly, no, the words Feel the Power are supposed to be slightly erased, although you're closer then you think.

Finally, sure I'll rate your sig. ;)

Firstly, I like how you included the fractal render and I think the main render (image) is blended in well, and looks great. However, I do think you tried to put too much in one sig. The problem with sigs is they're small. You've probably already seen how hard it is to get a lot into a single sig, and thats why I like making larger images, even though they can't really be used as sigs.

However, even though theres too much on the sig itself, I think you did a great job making the main render more visible and more important then the other renders, and I also think considering how much is on the sig, it actually looks suprisingly good. But for future reference, its a lot harder to fit quite a few renders into a single sig and make it look any good. Still, great job on that sig.

I'll rate it 8/10, because:

-Too crowded

+Great blending

+Use of fractal

+Looks impressive

=)

Cheers.

Yea, I overdue some signatures with crowding I guess, probably because I like the effect of memory that the opacity lowered render gives to the signature. And the smudge tool I used on Deidara's right side was an ultimate fail (its bumpy and some parts that are supposed to be smudged aren't).

Anyway, thank you! It means a lot! *curse my inability to seek out mistakes in an image*

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hey guys, I need my new avvie rated, please :) I was just doodling on a sticky note in pen and happened to like it, so I scanned it up and editted it to the colors of the theme I'm using.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
since its better than anything i can do.....7/10

how about my new sig? i had a sauske sig so why not a naruto one too :D

Well, the colors do contrast with your avatar...

7/10 (I guess that is the default rating......)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
since its better than anything i can do.....7/10

how about my new sig? i had a sauske sig so why not a naruto one too :D

What do you mean, it's better than anything you can do?

Edited by Okami
Ugh, I relooked at my post and thought "WHOATHEREGRAMMERNAZI!" :O Eep, sad grammer.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...