Background Rating Thread

[Narwhal]

Background Rating Thread

Hello, everyone! I've decided to start a thread where you can post backgrounds you've made and get them rated by others.

Rules:

• Follow the forum rules.
  
• Put backgrounds in spoilers.
  
• Don't post other people's work. (You can use brushes and renders etc.)
  
  
• Post one at a time. (separate posts)
  

Types of backgrounds:

• Signature Backgrounds
  
• Desktop Backgrounds
  
• Website Backgrounds
  
• Tilable Textures
  
• Background Pictures (Smaller than a background, but is still a background)
  
  

Have fun!

Edited September 18, 2009 by Narwhal

[Toffeuy]

I'll be first, rate this:

  Reveal hidden contents

  Reveal hidden contents

  Narwhal said:

• Don't post other people's work.
  

Does using other people's brushes count? (I used others' brushes to make the background) I just recently downloaded a few cool Photoshop brushes from deviantART, so I thought i'd use this as a chance to test them...

[Narwhal]

Nice, looks good for a Swampert and Blaziken sig.

Score: 86.9

Here's a desktop background I made.

  Reveal hidden contents

Edited August 29, 2009 by Narwhal

[Narwhal]

Anyone gonna rate my background?

[Ziz]

  Narwhal said:

Nice, looks good for a Swampert and Blaziken sig.

Score: 86.9

Here's a desktop background I made.

  Reveal hidden contents

8/10

Its really cool, but plain Its very easy to make that style of background, but I really like it

[Narwhal]

Here's another one.

  Reveal hidden contents

Made it earlier this year. It's not that good, but I want to know what people think about it.

[Toffeuy]

79.8/100

It's really good but Rayquaza won't really have that kind of pose while using a beam attack. And the beam looks a bit too big compared to Rayquaza.

[Narwhal]

Wow, didn't think that it would get that high of a rating. Here's ANOTHER.

  Reveal hidden contents

Don't expect this to get a high rating... :\ Render is kinda messed up. I'd give it a 65.8/100.

Edited September 17, 2009 by Narwhal

[Endless Eden]

this looks much better when it is a PS3 background but it chould be a desktop too..but it may be a bit big..(due to being a HD wallpaper for me)...,

  Reveal hidden contents

[Narwhal]

You made that? O_O If you did, 98.5/100. The only thing I don't like is the symbols make the text a little hard to read.

[Toffeuy]

Narwhal, i'll give yours a 1/2 or 50/100... Weavile, looks totally stuffed when it's red. And that spiky thing... it has the same colour as weavile and it has contact with Weavile... making it unable to tell if some parts are part of Weavile or not.

[Ziz]

  Narwhal said:

Wow, didn't think that it would get that high of a rating. Here's ANOTHER.

  Reveal hidden contents

Don't expect this to get a high rating... :\ Render is kinda messed up. I'd give it a 65.8/100.

Eh...it looks like copy & paste Weavile with a C4D kinda awkwardly placed in the middle. Add a color hue/color balance of red and some cool text and then that's all.

35/100

It lacked some effort

[Narwhal]

Yeah... :\

EDIT: Here's one I made today.

  Reveal hidden contents

I also have a background with Dragonair in this style.

Edited September 18, 2009 by Narwhal

[Illithian]

Simple, but interesting.

8/10

[Endless Eden]

i like this one better, (still very big for HD and it does look much better just a bit big )

  Reveal hidden contents

[Narwhal]

97.2/100. I <3 the hexagons.

[Endless Eden]

vector brushes :wink: among other things