Rayquaza911

33 minutes ago, theSLAYER said:

Not Legit. Not even Legal.
Until GameFreak provide Gen 2 VCs ^{(we already know its possibly planned, based on data in Sun/Moon)}, with the in-game Celebi event activated in some form ^{game patched or some real life event scenario},
none of the Gen 2 Celebi's will be legit/legal.

I can use ACE to obtain a Shiny Celebi in Pokemon Emerald without any external devices, but it still ain't legit, despite being "created within the bounds of the game".
 

IMO not Legit. (also it can't cross bank).

Even under a chain of circumstances (Trainer ID RNG'd or changed, on yourself or the Mew, and Trainer fly glitch Mew), it's at best Legal, not Legit.

Thanks, this is a good answer I was hoping for, I agree with you on the ACE in Emerald. Guess let the guy live in his own bubble then if it makes him happy I guess.

50 minutes ago, wejhvabewjty said:

There was a discussion here not too long about Gen 1 glitch Mew and if it should be considered legal or not. I would expect the same situation if the Gen 2 games get released but unless Pokémon/Nintendo releases an event that activates the flag IG those Celebis won't go through PokéBank.

Do you have a link to the thread? Are you talking about the VC Gen 1 Mew? It won't go through (at least mine wouldn't)  Bank but other glitched Pokemon (Ditto glitch) were able.

Sorry if this isn't the right place to ask but just wanted an opinion because this baffles me. I stumbled upon this First Ever LEGIT Shiny Celebi in Sun and Moon! Transferred from Crystal video, and the guy insists what he did was all legit and calls anyone who denies a troll or hater. Looking at his previous video on how he caught Celebi he used the GS Ball event and soft resetting in Ilex Forest, but it wasn't on a japanese version. After catching it he said he used Pokemon Editor Legacy Version to convert it to a 3gpkm file then using PKHEX to generate a QR code to bring it to Gen 7. Is this at all legal, and let's hypothesize that the VC for Gen 2 games does get released in the future, does that change anything? 

Wanted to report an error, for Kaphotic's Smogon Theme, there is no report link under the legality analysis

I wanted to report that my Nimbassa DW Pokemon you get from the trader aren't recognized, http://www.pokecheck.org/?p=box&bid=37&u=filip , so maybe you can update the LA with those pokes and add the Report Link for the Smogon Theme? Cause that one doesn't strain my eyes. Thx

EDIT: Ty for the fix on the link.