Jump to content
  • No uploading of Legend Arceus saves


    theSLAYER
     Share

    As we've received quite a few reports of save file verification blocking people from going online with public saves, we are currently removing every Legends Arceus save that is being uploaded. It will be removed with notice. Additionally, any future uploads will need approval before they appear publicly.

     

    For your sake, as well as others' sake, please don't upload Legend Arceus saves.


    Cheers.

    • V-Wheeeeeel!!! 1
    • Speechless 1
     Share


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Due to reports of savefile verification and savefile being banned if they are used by more than one account/switch, we STRONGLY suggest you don't use publicly uploaded savefiles obtained outside Project Pokémon either.

    Importing/exporting individual Pokémon files is safe, and uploads of .pa8 files/collections of .pa8 files will be permitted on Project Pokémon, but full savefiles will not be permitted, as it poses a potential ban risk for all users of said publicly shared savefile.

    • Like 4
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Wow, interesting - so they're now using Save file identification to ban Switch's using reoccurring save files? Which part of the save files do you think they're using as the "identifying factor"? Beyond just name/TID/SID? Is there an ID number for a save file itself now?

    Is there anywhere we can read more about this particular "issue"?

    Edited by english09
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    would trading pokes between a public save on a banned switch to my own on a not banned do anything?

     

    jw cause the could start blacklisting OT's/TID's on public saves and ban people having traded pokes from those blacklisted

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Unfounded speculation: I think they may be storing the profile’s Nintendo Account’s unique ID somewhere, not just plain OT/TID/SID.

    Or, hear me out. Saves that goes online in older games get a unique identifier issued from the server. The server could log and pair your Nintendo Account and the Unique identifier on their end. So sorta like a HOME tracker situation: server logs data and matches it to the tracker (or in this case the unique identifier). 
     

    Could they log OT/TID/SID combo of people who have done bad bad trades? They could, we don’t know. We don’t work for them.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Are the reports of console bans or just game bans?

    Do we know if anybody has tried migrating their save file to another Switch (using non-official tools e.g. JKSV) and injecting the save to a user tied to the same Nintendo account? Does this result in the same type of ban?

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    10 hours ago, arjjjjjjie said:

    Are the reports of console bans or just game bans?

    Do we know if anybody has tried migrating their save file to another Switch (using non-official tools e.g. JKSV) and injecting the save to a user tied to the same Nintendo account? Does this result in the same type of ban? 

    Not even game bans, the "ban" is lifted if you stop using the blacklisted savefile.

    The ban does not occur with official transfer methods, like local save transfer between two switches within the same Nintendo account. I would assume if the Nintendo account remains the same, their check clears, even if you moved it with JKSV or Checkpoint.

    Edited by Atrius97
    • Thanks 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    So...don't go online with them? I'd never go online with saves I downloaded anyway.

     

    I feel like SAVs should still be allowed, just obviously don't go online with them. That's a given.

    Edited by PLAFiles
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    3 hours ago, PLAFiles said:

    So...don't go online with them? I'd never go online with saves I downloaded anyway.

     

    I feel like SAVs should still be allowed, just obviously don't go online with them. That's a given.

    No means no.

    If we don’t even host saves, people can’t “not read the don’t go online” warning and won’t end up online a shared save.

    If we host saves, people can “not read the don’t go online” part; they’ll go online without ever seeing the warnings.

    Besides, those are only reported and observed issues. There could be more issues than that weren’t observed and thus went unreported. Something like this was theorised by mods privately, so we are not at all surprised to see it happen. Only surprised it took them so long. 

    So until something changes (like the reports were proven to be bad, and/or it’s not as bad as initially reported etc),  I don’t foresee changing that ruling.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    you really would' expect bdsp to impliment this first mainly cause PLA only has a trade function and no online battling so i agree a dumb move to impliment it this late in the switches life cycle shoulda done it wit sw/sh

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    14 hours ago, pokedummy227 said:

    you really would' expect bdsp to impliment this first mainly cause PLA only has a trade function and no online battling so i agree a dumb move to impliment it this late in the switches life cycle shoulda done it wit sw/sh

    They implemented this new verification into ACNH quite late. There is no reason they can't decide suddenly to implement it for LGPE, SWSH, or BDSP.
    There's a HOME compatibility update on the horizon, I don't expect them to suddenly upgrade verification for all 6 remaining game versions, but the chance isn't zero.

    • Like 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    On 2/8/2022 at 3:53 AM, Atrius97 said:

    Not even game bans, the "ban" is lifted if you stop using the blacklisted savefile.

    The ban does not occur with official transfer methods, like local save transfer between two switches within the same Nintendo account. I would assume if the Nintendo account remains the same, their check clears, even if you moved it with JKSV or Checkpoint.

    Interesting. Are there multiple reports that corroborate this? Any that refute it? It sounds like (with my limited knowledge of how Nintendo/TPCi do this) the game generates a UUID for the save when it first connects to the internet and checks it against its database of other saves’ UUIDs. If the UUID already exists, it blocks access. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    6 hours ago, arjjjjjjie said:

    Interesting. Are there multiple reports that corroborate this? Any that refute it? It sounds like (with my limited knowledge of how Nintendo/TPCi do this) the game generates a UUID for the save when it first connects to the internet and checks it against its database of other saves’ UUIDs. If the UUID already exists, it blocks access. 

    There are multiple reports about it, hence why said ruling is in place here. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    7 hours ago, arjjjjjjie said:

    Interesting. Are there multiple reports that corroborate this? Any that refute it? It sounds like (with my limited knowledge of how Nintendo/TPCi do this) the game generates a UUID for the save when it first connects to the internet and checks it against its database of other saves’ UUIDs. If the UUID already exists, it blocks access. 

    Given how GameSync ID used to work for prior games, this is very likely the case. Unfortunately, we can't trust players would upload exclusively saves that had never been online before, and the Project Pokemon staff would be forced to verify each savefile individually.

    On the other side of that coin, exposing that value publicly to be edited/"removed from saves that had been online before" opens up an avenue for potential abuse/exploits that could cause TPCi to introduce additional telemetry and/or kick off another banwave.

    Edited by Atrius97
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I've flagged the account as spammer, and removed the offending post. In the future you can just report the post to us :3
    (as in when you click on the 3 dots at the top right hand corner of the post, there's actually a report feature :) )

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Hi! I know save file is banned, but does that apply to Save Pokemon as well? Say for example I want to share my perfect IV GV Gardevoir with others to use. Am I allowed to upload that specific Pokemon here?

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    2 hours ago, StarryMiracle said:

    Hi! I know save file is banned, but does that apply to Save Pokemon as well? Say for example I want to share my perfect IV GV Gardevoir with others to use. Am I allowed to upload that specific Pokemon here?

    Pokémon are fine as long as they're legal.

    For example, you can upload a single mon (.pa8) or as a binary dump from PKHeX for the entire PC (pcdata.bin)

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

  • Our picks

    • Since they released over a decade ago, the Pokémon Mystery Dungeon games for the Nintendo DS have not had much in the way of ROM editors. Over the past few years, hackers have slowly learned more and more about the inner workings of the games, culminating in the most advanced PMD editor to date: Sky Temple. 

      SkyTemple is a user-friendly level editor for Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers of Sky that gives the user full control over graphics, scripts, Pokémon data, and more, enabling a great amount of creative freedom to prospective ROM hackers to create not just edits of the game, but entirely new levels and plots.

      See the trailer for the version 1.0.0 release for quick samples of what can be accomplished:

      Additional reading:

      Download:

       
        • Amazed
        • Like
      • 6 replies
    • The #1 issue with Gates to Infinity is the super slow text speed. Luckily, @shutterbug2000 discovered how to fix it.
      • 32 replies
    • PKHeX 20.01.10
      PKHeX is a save editor for core-series Pokémon games. With it, users can manipulate various save files including: .sav, .dsv, .dat, .gci, .raw, and .bin types. PKHeX can also read and write: .pk files, which are individual Pokémon files, and .pgt, .pcd, .pgf, .wc, which are Mystery Gift files.

      Version 20.01.10 of PKHeX has been released! PKHeX now supports the latest patch (1.1.0) Full change log below!

       

       

      Change log:

      Download      |     FAQ     |     Support Forum
        • Thanks
      • 1 reply
    • Website Updates
      After a few hours of being offline, we're finally back! Not only are we on a shiny new server, we have some new goodies.
        • Hahaha
        • Amazed
        • V-Wheeeeeel!!!
        • Thanks
        • Like
      • 7 replies
    • Following the success of his fan dub of Pokémon Super Mystery Dungeon, YouTuber TheGoldCrow has started a new project: a fan dub of Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers of Sky.
        • V-Wheeeeeel!!!
        • Like
      • 2 replies
×
×
  • Create New...